Hello, we aren’t Walt Mossberg…

Comments Off

We don’t like the animosity in the mobile media. Really, we don’t.

But when Phone Scoop’s Eric Lin publicly made a foul-four-letter-word-strewn commentary about PhoneNews.com nabbing the first review of the Palm Pre, we realized animosity was alive and well in the mobile media.

And while it’s true, many don’t like our review style, it’s different… not phony. Other sites can claim they don’t like our review style, but that doesn’t give them the ethics to say they were first to a review of the final Palm Pre.

We don’t write reviews that take into account personal preferences. Hence, the title. That’s not to say we don’t like Walt Mossberg (we do actually), we just find we have a different audience. For example, on the keyboard, half the staff likes it, half the staff doesn’t. Same with many other keyboards on phones. So, we let you decide how you like it. After all, if the staff finds different takes on a device… that means there’s a diverse range of opinion on it.

These are expensive gadgets, and we’re not going to impose our opinions on subjective matters. Others are welcomed to do so, in their editorial styles.

It’s unfortunate that Boy Genius Report has chosen to lie about its claim to the first hand-on review of the final Palm Pre. It’s even more unfortunate that Apple-centric media, like MacNN (also known by its smaller news service, Electronista), and MacRumors have chosen to drink the kool-aid, and sanction Boy Genius Report’s claims.

To the media’s credit, most aren’t drinking the kool-aid. Others have given independent opinions that provide independent analysis (and, yes, we linked to one that didn’t like our review so much… just to be fair and balanced here).

Both MacNN and MacRumors are familiar with PhoneNews.com. They are of course held to the same standard… they may not like our review (or, like Phone Scoop, even dislike us), but that doesn’t give them the right to ignore our reporting.

For most though, the solution to this problem is simple. Park our RSS feed in your feed reader, and see for yourself. We’ve been in the mobile media, since there was a mobile media. We’re only growing from here.

P.S. We’ve posted plenty of photos of the Pre in the past (which loads PhoneNews.com without trouble, as we’ve shown in the past). Feel free to search the news.

Because of abuse, we’ve disabled commentary on this blog posting. Please don’t feed the trolls.

Trackback | Permalink |

We Hear You: Trackbacks to Be Separated

Leave a Comment

You’ve asked, and we’ll be delivering. Trackbacks will be separated from comments this week, enabling you to sort through the discussion easily.

Tabbed comments are something else we’re looking into, but won’t be coming this week.

Update: Ran into a few issues, but fear not, it will be coming when we get back from E3…

Trackback | Permalink |

Yeah, another wave of downtime…

2 Comments

Gotta love Murphy’s Law. Well, since CTIA has sucked, we’re going to make up for that shortly.

However, this downtime was caused by a set of hard drive failures, following the failure of a RAID head right before the show.

This reminds me of all the crud that broked during CES. Murphy’s Law… but hey, it’s only money (we keep saying that to ourselves… or rather, I keep saying that to myself). We’ll win you back with free stuff.

Update: Sorry folks, the drives are still acting wonky. We have people on it.

Trackback | Permalink |

Photos Are Coming

Leave a Comment

Stay tuned later today, for a double dose of photos. We wanted to get some photos in, but our 10 AM product announcement has taken priority.

Don’t worry, you’ll see all the photos the other guys won’t have period. And, as usual, they’ll all be in beautiful HD.

Trackback | Permalink |

Ongoing Server Issues

Leave a Comment

We’re having new server issues today (Murphy’s Law). We’ve been working on them since 3 AM. We’re still working on it.

Update: Fixed.

Trackback | Permalink |

This Morning’s Outage

Leave a Comment

Sorry for the outage this morning, which lasted between 90 minutes and two hours.

No, we weren’t testing anything coming soon. It was a RAID card that failed on our off-site server. Card was replaced, server’s back.

Trackback | Permalink |

Minor Cashback Delay

Leave a Comment

Cashback mailings and payments will likely be delayed for a few days over the next week. This is due to the previously-announced move that MechaWorks is making, to new offices located in Silicon Valley.

But, when we do touch down in the Valley, we’re going to make getting cashback up to speed a priority.

If there are any additional delays, we’ll get in touch and announce it on the main PhoneNews.com Cashback site. But, we don’t forsee any delays beyond this one.

Trackback | Permalink |

Farewell, RCR

1 Comment

RCR Wireless closed its doors yesterday, after 25 years in the wireless business. With over five times the tenure, I have to admit, we enjoyed the competition.

The publication tried to stay hip to the times, but when the Web 2.0 economy met the Global Recession economy, they had to shut down. This isn’t a post to mock them… it’s pretty clear that they did what they could to keep an old-world publishing platform as modern as it could be.

But, what really scratched my head about RCR, was how it couldn’t find a niche. It tried to be the insider journal in all-things-wireless. With huge over-the-top overheads, I was amazed each year that the bought up massive floor space at CTIA. It’s pretty clear that was running on ad budgests that shrank to zero when the economy declined. And, while they did try to compete with PhoneNews.com in the device and carrier news… it wasn’t an earnest enough effort. They couldn’t gain a new niche, and lost the old one at the same time.

This is really a lesson in rolling with the punches. We’ve certainly learned that here at PhoneNews.com in this economy. But, we intend to stay in the game. We’re honored to maintain viewership that we have, and we intend to keep delivering the same quality of news… no matter how bad it gets out there.

Trackback | Permalink |

Apple Pulls Old iPhone Firmware

Leave a Comment

Shortly after we posted all the old iPhone firmware download links on our Apple Phone Encyclopedia section, Apple has taken them offline.

It’s pretty clear why they did this… old iPhone firmwares are only useful to those who hack the iPhone. And, by taking them offline, Apple ensures that it’s one step harder to obtain the tools needed to unlock the iPhone.

Our real question is… why did Apple let those firmwares stay up for this long? iPhone has been out for nearly two years, before Apple pulled the plug on hosting old firmware versions.

And, we think we know the answer. Apple recently asked the U.S. Copyright Office to not remove iPhone hacks from the list of DMCA-protected acts, and took the legal opinion (two years too late) that hacking your iPhone is illegal. This came as the EFF is asking the USCO to make iPhone hacking unquestionably legal, by removing any DMCA vaguries via an exemption.

Thus, Apple couldn’t keep tacitly permitting jailbreaking. Apple of course wants to support jailbreaking, so long as it doesn’t become mainstream (since jailbreaking keeps the Apple base happy, but without being popular enough to undermine their business model). So, as Apple asks the USCO to change the rules of the game, they have to remove the old firmwares… keeping their policy consistent on all fronts.

One final thing… Apple left up the original iPhone old firmwares, while only pulling the iPhone 3G old firmwares. It’s pretty clear that Apple doesn’t care if original iPhones get hacked, which is supported by their lack of attempts to protect the SIM lock on it. Unlocking original iPhones help maintain the resale value of Apple products in general… boosting Apple’s bottom line, by reducing the cost difference between old-and-new models.

Trackback | Permalink |

The First Prepaid Phone Challenge Payments

Leave a Comment

They’re being mailed! We’ve gotten quite a few emails from people that didn’t read the details… and didn’t notice that we had to hold the gift cards for 30 days.

To review, we had to begin holding the Best Buy gift cards for 30 days, because some took it upon themselves to return the free phone. Why they wanted to return a free phone… I have no idea. But, we can’t pay people for sending back a phone (that actually winds up costing more when you factor in the return shipping).

So, those are being mailed out as we speak. We’ve mailed a good third of them already, and we expect everyone’s to be sent out in the mail… by week’s end.

And yes, for the new challenge (announced this morning), there will also be a 30 day hold. Don’t blame us, blame the geniuses that decided to return a free phone.

Trackback | Permalink |